← Resources

Playbooks

Seo competitors

Step-by-step on finding your actual SEO competitors (not your branding competitors), auditing what they're doing, and identifying the gap to outrank them.

Updated

Before you start

  • A list of 3-5 keywords that drive meaningful organic traffic to your site
  • Access to one SEO tool (Ahrefs, SEMrush, SpyFu, or Ubersuggest)
  • 30-45 minutes for the first audit, then 15 minutes monthly to maintain

The playbook

7 steps

0/7

  1. Forget your branding competitors. Find your SERP competitors.

    Most teams confuse 'competitors we think about' with 'competitors we actually compete with on Google'. They're often different sets. Nike's branding competitor is Adidas; Nike's SEO competitor for 'best running shoes 2026' may be Wirecutter or RunRepeat. Run the SEO competitor exercise; don't assume.

    TipThe fastest test: search your top 5 organic keywords manually. The top 10 results for each are your SERP competitors. Some will surprise you.

    Expected outcome

    You have a list of 5-10 domains that consistently outrank you (or rank alongside you) on your priority keywords.

  2. Use a competitor-discovery tool to confirm

    In Ahrefs: Site Explorer → Competing Domains. In SEMrush: Domain Overview → Competitors. In SpyFu: type your domain → see organic competitors. Each tool's algorithm scores 'competitiveness' based on keyword overlap; the top 10 are your actual SEO competitors regardless of what marketing thinks.

    Expected outcome

    Your manual list from step 1 is cross-validated against the tool's algorithmic competitor list.

  3. Run the Content Gap report

    In Ahrefs: Site Explorer → Content Gap. Input your domain plus 2-3 confirmed competitors. The report surfaces every keyword they rank for that you don't. **This is the single highest-leverage SEO competitive output you'll produce** - it's literally a list of articles you should write, ordered by traffic potential.

    # Example workflow:
# 1. Your domain: shuttergen.com
# 2. Competitor 1: foreplay.co
# 3. Competitor 2: atria.so
# Output: 800-2,500 keywords they rank for that we don't

    Expected outcome

    You have a prioritized list of keywords to target, ranked by competitor traffic and difficulty.

  4. Filter the gap report to actionable keywords

    Most content gap reports return more keywords than you can act on. Filter to: (1) keyword difficulty under your domain's authority threshold (typically KD < your DR × 1.2); (2) monthly search volume > 100; (3) intent matches your business model (commercial / informational; skip navigational queries to competitor brand names).

    Expected outcome

    The 800-2,500 keyword gap collapses to 50-200 actionable keyword opportunities.

  5. Audit the top-ranked article for each priority keyword

    For your top 20 priority keywords, click into the #1 ranking article on Google. Read it. Note: word count, header structure (H2 / H3 patterns), internal link count, schema markup, image count, content angle. The pattern across the 20 is the template you need to match or beat.

    TipTop-ranking articles converge in structure within a niche. If 18 of 20 use a numbered listicle format and your article is essay-style, you're structurally disadvantaged before the content quality even matters.

    Expected outcome

    You have a structural template that summarizes how content in your niche ranks - word count, format, depth, multimedia.

  6. Identify the backlink gap

    In Ahrefs: Site Explorer → Backlink Gap. Input your domain + top 3 competitors. The report shows every domain linking to competitors that doesn't link to you. **The backlink gap is harder to close than the content gap** - it requires outreach, partnerships, or genuinely link-worthy content. But it's where SEO competitive moats actually live.

    Expected outcome

    A list of 50-200 referring domains worth pursuing for linking partnerships or guest content.

  7. Build a monthly tracking dashboard

    Set up a recurring monthly check: top 20 priority keyword positions for you vs competitors, content gap delta (are new keywords appearing on competitors' sites you should target?), backlink delta (are competitors acquiring links from new sources?). 30 minutes per month maintained over 12 months produces compounded SEO intelligence.

    TipMost teams skip this. The ones that maintain the monthly cadence consistently outpace competitors over 12-18 months despite shipping no more content per month.

    Expected outcome

    A maintained monthly dashboard that catches competitive shifts before they cost you ranking positions.

Shuttergen

SEO research finds the keywords. Shuttergen ships the ads.

Once you know which competitors rank, the next step is shipping creative that outperforms theirs in paid channels. Shuttergen generates that creative tuned to your category's winners.

Generate competitive creative freeAnatomy of a competitive audit →

Pitfalls

What goes wrong

  • Treating brand competitors as SEO competitors

    Your direct brand competitors may not be your SEO competitors. Run the SERP-based discovery from step 1; trust the data over your intuition.

  • Trying to cover every gap keyword

    Content gap reports return more keywords than any team can ship. Filter aggressively and prioritize ruthlessly - 50 well-targeted articles beat 200 mediocre ones.

  • Ignoring keyword difficulty

    Targeting keywords your domain authority can't rank for wastes content investment. Stick to KD < your DR × 1.2 unless you're shipping pillar content with explicit link-acquisition support.

  • Skipping the backlink gap analysis

    Content gaps are easier to spot and feel more actionable, so teams over-invest in content and under-invest in links. Link gaps explain why two articles of similar quality rank differently; close the link gap or accept the ranking gap.

  • Running the audit once and never again

    Competitive landscapes shift. The team that ran an audit in January and never repeated it is operating on stale data by July. Maintain the monthly cadence.

Limits

When this playbook won't work

  • Your priority keywords are zero-volume - no audit will turn a $0 keyword into $0+ traffic
  • Your domain authority is too low to compete on any of the target keywords (build authority first, audit second)
  • Your category has effectively no competitors with SEO investment - audit different niches with comparable category dynamics
  • Your business model doesn't depend on organic traffic - the audit value is bounded by how much organic matters

Why finding the right competitors matters more than the audit method

The audit method is roughly standardized: content gap, backlink gap, top-ranked article forensics, monthly tracking. Every serious SEO consultant runs roughly the same playbook. What separates good audits from useless ones is picking the right competitors in the first place.

The wrong competitor list produces audit output that misleads. If you audit Adidas while your real SEO competitor is RunRepeat, the content gap report surfaces keywords that don't move the needle for your business. If you audit your direct competitor's homepage when their real SEO traction is from blog content, the audit misses where the rankings actually live.

Spend 20% of your audit time picking competitors and 80% running the audit. Most teams do it backwards. The picking is the load-bearing decision; the audit method is the execution.

SEO research finds the keywords. Shuttergen ships the ads. Once you know which competitors rank, the next step is shipping creative that outperforms theirs in paid channels. Shuttergen generates that creative tuned to your category's winners.

Generate competitive creative free

When to use which SEO tool for this audit

Ahrefs is the deepest for content gap + backlink gap analysis. If you can only afford one tool, this is it. The Content Gap report alone is worth the subscription for most SEO-driven businesses.

SEMrush is comparable to Ahrefs on most dimensions and stronger on PPC integration. Pick SEMrush if you want one tool for both PPC and SEO competitive work.

SpyFu is cheaper and PPC-deeper. For SEO competitor work specifically, SpyFu is the weakest of the three - usable for keyword discovery but thin on backlinks and content gap polish. See spyfu-vs-ahrefs.

Ubersuggest / Mangools / Serpstat are the budget tier. Usable for early-stage businesses where the audit budget is tight; you'll outgrow them by the time you're maintaining a monthly competitive dashboard.

Internal: find-competitors, find-seo-competitors, how-to-find-website-competitors.

FAQ

Frequently asked

How do I find my SEO competitors?
Two methods, used together: (1) manually search your top 5 organic keywords and note the top 10 results, (2) use Ahrefs / SEMrush / SpyFu's competitor-discovery feature to algorithmically identify domains with high keyword overlap. The intersection is your actual competitive set.
Are my SEO competitors the same as my business competitors?
Often not. Business competitors compete for the same customers; SEO competitors compete for the same keywords. The two sets overlap but aren't identical - run the SERP-based discovery rather than assuming.
What's the best tool for SEO competitor analysis?
Ahrefs - deepest content gap + backlink gap features in the category. SEMrush is comparable and stronger for PPC integration. SpyFu and budget alternatives work for early-stage but you'll outgrow them.
How often should I audit SEO competitors?
Deep audit annually or after major site changes. Monthly tracking dashboard for the 20 priority keywords + content gap delta. Quarterly review of new competitor entrants. The monthly cadence is where the compounding lives.
How many SEO competitors should I track?
5-10. More than that and the maintenance overhead dominates the value. Pick the 5-10 that actually move when you watch their rankings; track them deeply; ignore the long tail.
Can I find SEO competitors without paying for tools?
Manually, yes - search your top keywords and note the top 10. For depth (content gap, backlink gap), you need a paid tool. The free path covers the discovery; the paid path covers the audit.

Related

Keep reading

Resource

Find seo competitors

Sister keyword - same process.

Resource

Find competitors

Broader competitor-finding workflow.

Resource

How to find competitors of a website

Website-specific approach.

Resource

Seo analysis of competition

Deeper analysis methodology.

Research

Anatomy Of Good Meta Ad Library

Adjacent competitive audit framework.

SEO research finds the keywords. Shuttergen ships the ads.

Once you know which competitors rank, the next step is shipping creative that outperforms theirs in paid channels. Shuttergen generates that creative tuned to your category's winners.

Generate competitive creative freeAnatomy of a competitive audit →